twitter orange   linkedin orange   googleplus orange


25 Feb
“Independence” a vexed question when tenant reps share office with landlord reps

With Mario Macri, Director ACORPP


Prospective and existing tenants are at the mercy of a curious set of industry dynamics where the typical multinational real estate agencies organising their lease can often also be representing their landlord.

ACORPP Director Mario Macri said that exacerbating this odd state of affairs was that tenants were quite often unaware that they were in the middle of this potential conflict of interest.

“If they are aware, they have usually been assured that there is an intra-company ‘Chinese wall’ between the parties representing them and the landlord,” Mr Macri said.

20160302 Collage Shutterstock


Mr Macri said such assurances were open to challenge where both parties were often housed in the same office and shared the same computer network and disclosed information to the same directors.

“It stretches the bounds of believability that these individuals, often in side-by-side cubicles, are not going to share information, particularly when there is an overarching demand on them to get a deal done quickly,” he said.

Mr Macri said this raised two key questions.

“How can you have any confidence in the independence of advice given to you as a tenant when there is potential for a conflict of interest - and how will you ever know you got the best deal that you could?” he said.

“These are the type of issues that should keep you awake at night if you’ve ever signed a deal in these circumstances.”

Mr Macri was quick to dispel notions that any of these types of practices might be endorsed or applied in the WA or QLD market.

“Not at all, but the mere fact that a tenant representative and a landlord representative can both be from the same company must at least raise a question on the independence of advice that might be offered,” he said.

“Another perspective is: will the agency work harder for a landlord where they will earn ongoing property fees as opposed to the interests of a single transaction tenant?”


mm article


The ACORPP director believes there should be a duty of disclosure where parties declared their common backgrounds, giving both a tenant and a landlord the option to proceed or opt out of having the agency represent both sides of the negotiation.

“This would at least ensure parties are proceeding with their eyes wide open,” Mr Macri said.

Mr Macri said the ACORPP tenant representation proposal was unambiguous.

“If we are representing you, all our efforts are directed toward getting you the best possible outcome,” he said.

“We work for no other interests other than yours.”



ACORPP Market Voice - Three Things Tenants Can Do Now to Make Savings
ACORPP Construction Market Voice - Industry will have to “tier down” to survive
Perth office further improves its energy performance
Brisbane office gets top draft pick with ex-Lions ruckman
Former Greek Swimming Star Joins ACORPP Perth Office
Out of the Vault and into a snappy Christmas





Latest News

28 Jun
Rent free periods: The real cost

Office vacancy rates in Perth continue to edge upwards, but any signs of stabilisation may take a hit when Woodside’s new headquarters is completed, and that’s projected to be by the end of this year.

27 Jun
Construction: Where the work is

A snapshot of the national construction sector tells us one thing: the only certainty is the uncertainty.

26 Jun
World body (RICS) speaks out against agents who double dip

The world’s foremost global real estate accreditation body that certifies property and construction professionals has banned the practice of dual agency representation in the UK.